Taking a policy loan doesn't create a tax bill by itself. On LIFE Pod Ep 96, James and Carlo Viqueira went through what does: a policy that lapses while a large loan is still outstanding. A lapse means the policy ends because there's no longer enough value inside it to keep it going. If the policy had gains in it, which means cash value above what you paid in premium, those gains can become reportable income in the year it lapses. The tax bill that arrives when a loaned-up policy lapses covers how that income is figured.
What usually sinks a policy is the interest on the loan. Interest you don't pay gets added to the loan balance, and over time that balance can grow until it passes the limit the contract allows against your cash value. That's when a lapse can happen. It matters most once the policy has gains, which takes a few years in some designs and a lot of years in others.
James's test for how much borrowing is too much comes down to one question: can you pay the interest? He used an example of $1 million in loans carrying $50,000 a year in interest. If your normal paycheck covers that $50,000 comfortably, he said he has no problem with it, even if you've borrowed almost everything out. Once the interest is something you're sweating over, you've borrowed too much. Carlo added the habit that goes with it. Keep track of your loan-to-cash-value ratio, which means the loan balance divided by the cash value, whether you're borrowing during your building years or drawing in retirement.
The worst case they described is an indexed universal life policy, or IUL, bought as a retirement income plan. The owner draws income through loans, the market has down years so the policy gets no index credits, the cash value runs low, and the policy lapses. The income stops, and a tax bill on the gains shows up on top of it. James said he doesn't like to sell IULs for retirement income or illustrate income in them. He and Carlo treat a policy as a volatility buffer, meaning money you tap in years when your market accounts are down, as one part of an overall plan. It isn't their primary retirement vehicle.
Most IULs, and at least one whole life policy, offer an overloan protection rider. When the loan reaches a set share of the cash value, usually around 95% or a little higher, and you've reached the carrier's age threshold, which is 65 with some carriers and 75 with others, you can trigger the rider. The insurance company then keeps a minimum death benefit in force until you die, so the policy doesn't lapse and the tax bill never comes. James called it a fail-safe you pull on purpose, and said you still want to avoid getting close to that limit by accident. The rider that keeps a loaned-up policy from lapsing goes through it in more detail.
In an IUL, whether you get that rider usually depends on which MEC test the policy is designed under. A MEC, or modified endowment contract, is a policy funded too fast for the tax rules, and it loses some of its tax advantages. Two tests set that limit. Whole life uses the cash value accumulation test. An IUL lets you choose between that one and the guideline premium test. The cash value accumulation test requires a bigger death benefit compared to the cash value, which makes a guaranteed minimum death benefit more expensive for the carrier, so most carriers James knows of won't put the overloan protection rider on an IUL designed that way. If you expect to borrow heavily from an IUL later, ask for the rider by name and expect it to come with the guideline premium test. Guideline premium or cash value accumulation explains the two tests side by side.
Most of the time a cash value policy sends you no tax forms at all. You borrow against it, pay the loans back, and there's nothing to report. James named two situations where the insurance company does send a 1099-R, the form that reports a taxable distribution. One is a lapse or a cancellation with gains in the policy. The other is a MEC. In a MEC, withdrawals come out gains first, and loans are treated the same as withdrawals, so borrowing against it can be taxed as income.
If the policy stays in force and isn't a MEC, loans can generally be taken income-tax-free, because any loan still outstanding at death is subtracted from a death benefit that passes income-tax-free. An outstanding loan does reduce the cash value you can reach and the death benefit your family receives. James is a licensed insurance broker, not a CPA, so talk to a tax professional about how this applies to you.
Pull your latest annual statement, divide the loan balance by the cash value, and write down what a full year of loan interest costs you before you borrow again.