If your indexed universal life policy has its anniversary in November, you have a decision to make. An indexed universal life policy, or IUL, credits interest to your cash value based on how a stock market index does. Once a year, on the policy anniversary, you choose where the money goes for the next 12 months. Those choices are called index options, and most of them are tied to the S&P 500 in some way. In the November 2026 IUL Playbook, recorded November 19, James Barber went through what the market was doing and how he is setting up his own renewals. There was no October playbook. The September episode goes through every index option in detail, and this one is shorter.

As of November 19, the S&P 500 was down almost 9% from its all-time high, sitting just above a sideways stretch from late 2025. There was a lot of volatility, and a midterm election had just happened. James pointed to a statistic he uses for midterm years: since 1939, the S&P 500 has been up in the year after a midterm election every time. He treats that as a guide and not a guarantee. The same history shows an average drop of about 16% at some point during that year, so a 9% drop so far is inside the normal range. If the index keeps falling, he sees the next likely support area around 7,000.

He also laid out the bear case. The economy could be heading into a recession or already in one. Inflation and oil prices are still up. Housing is weak, with high rates keeping buyers out, and car loan defaults are high. AI stocks pushed the market up earlier in the year, and most of them have since fallen at least 50%. NVIDIA dropped about 30% over a couple of weeks, and Apple is now the largest company in the market. James said there's no reason to assume those stocks are done falling. On the other side, he explained why the S&P 500 tends to climb over time: it's weighted, so the companies doing best carry more weight, the losers get dropped from the index, and a large amount of money has to stay invested somewhere.

With all that, James is playing what he calls optimistic defense in the Allianz IUL, which most of his playbooks cover. That means a few specific choices:

  • Skip the higher bonus option. Some index options let you pay an extra 1% charge for a bigger bonus. He isn't paying it this year. If he uses any of the uncapped options, which are options with no cap, meaning no upper limit on the credit, he would use the classic bonus option.
  • Look hard at the S&P trigger. A trigger option pays a set rate if the index is flat or up on your next anniversary. As of the recording it was paying around 8%. If the S&P 500 is negative a year from your anniversary, you don't get the 8%.
  • Look hard at the fixed interest account. This is the part of the policy that pays a declared interest rate with no index involved. As of the recording it was well above 5%, about 5.3%. If you have no policy loan, James said there's nothing wrong with taking 5.3% while the economy and the market are this uncertain. When to put IUL money in the fixed account goes into that choice.

If you have a loan against the policy, James likes the trigger together with the participating index loan option. With that loan option, the cash value you borrowed against keeps getting index credits while the loan charges interest, so you can come out ahead when the credit is higher than the loan rate. He called that a good arbitrage opportunity right now. It works the other way in a year the index credits nothing, because you still owe the loan interest.

Where the index sits on your own anniversary date matters. To get back to its high, the S&P 500 would have to climb roughly 8 to 9%, which is about what the trigger pays. If your anniversary lands after a further drop, there's more room for a bounce, and James said the lower it goes, the more willing he is to switch from defense to offense. In that case he would look at the uncapped options or the S&P point-to-point with a cap. Point-to-point compares the index on one anniversary to the next and credits the gain up to the cap. If a bounce pushes the index up more than 8%, those options could beat the trigger. If your anniversary came earlier in the month when the index was higher, he said you might feel more comfortable with the fixed interest account. Keep in mind he also said timing the market is very hard, and the market doesn't always match what's happening in the rest of the economy.

The trigger rate, the fixed rate and the bonus charge are what was available as of November 19. They change, and your own renewal notice shows the numbers you can actually pick from. James Barber is a licensed insurance broker, not a registered investment advisor, and none of this is advice on any particular investment. If your anniversary is coming up, pull your renewal notice and compare the trigger rate, the fixed account rate, and your loan balance before you choose, or schedule an annual policy review to go through them with him.